Results Based Analysis (RBA) is a powerful organisational tool which can provide data to monitor progress and evaluate why services, programmes and interventions are succeeding or failing.
RBA provides a basis for answering the questions:
- What are we trying to achieve, and why?
- How are we progressing?
- Have the desired results been achieved?
Evaluation using an RBA approach , in practice, can help to answer different, but equally important questions:
- What are the results we want to achieve?
- Why were results achieved or not?
- What is the connection between intervention and outcome?
- Do we need to repeat or discard anything we do?
- Have there been any unintended consequences?
- How do we need to change?
Val Connors, our associate consultant, recently ran a seminar on how RBA maybe used effectively to enhance business planning and the development of the ACRF within Wales. Here are some reflective notes based on the discussions held.
Perceived benefits of RBA
- Increases opportunities for engagement of ‘customers’ and other stakeholders in a shared vision and how to achieve it
- Increases ownership of outcomes and means
- Supports creativity and ensures interventions are relevant and timely
- Provides a gateway to move from a reactive to a proactive culture
- Provides increased opportunity to explore how joint intervention can be integrated to achieve shared outcomes
- Improves ‘customer’ focus by examining success and failure through collection and analysis of ‘customer' experiences
- Supports more accurate commissioning of internal/external services
- Improved performance management, better use of resources
- Provides a continuing opportunity to demonstrate results and build public confidence
- Can cut across departmental , corporate and collaborative joint‐planning processes
- Supports political scrutiny and organisational governance
Challenges
- The focus of RBA must be on outcomes and improvement
- Careful choice of performance measures is critical
- Data should be chosen to illuminate difficult issues, rather than to show the organisation in the most favorable light
- If RBA is to become more than a ‘flavour of the month' concept, personnel must see a direct link between what they do and the data they collect
- Implementing, organisation wide RBA, needs a longer‐term strategy with a shared language
- Collaboration and trust will be needed, if RBA is to deliver required results, particularly in
relation to population accountability - Welsh Assembly Government PIs do not fit well with an RBA approach and will need to be
adjusted - In return for measurable results, agencies, with commissioning and contracting
responsibilities, will need to delegate authority and resources
Implementing & RBA will require additional capacity to:
- Develop a shared language
- Engage customers and stakeholders
- Set clear outcomes
- Agree shared indicators and measures of success
- Collect and use data beneficially
The current financial climate is challenging. Sharing costs in a collaborative venture, across
geographical and agency boundaries, offers a possible solution to the issue of capacity.
Gabe Conlon
Practice Solutions
17.1.2011